Choose based on what you need. An agency gives you a team and lots of services under one roof; an independent media buyer gives you a direct line to the person spending your money. Either way, ask for the same things: accounts in your name, business metrics, pricing you understand and reports that explain decisions.
What’s actually different between an agency and an independent media buyer?
Quick disclaimer up front: I work as an independent media buyer, so read this with that in mind. I’m going to try to be fair, because picking the wrong partner is expensive for anyone, and there are businesses that are better off with an agency than with me.
The real difference is who touches your money and how many layers sit between that person and you. At an agency there’s usually an account manager who talks to you and a team that does the work. With an independent, you talk directly to the person building and optimizing your campaigns.
This is the comparison I use to explain how I work. It’s my take, not a law of nature: there are great agencies that do everything in the right-hand column.
| Traditional agency (the usual) | Working with me |
|---|---|
| You talk to an account manager who relays the message. | You talk directly to the person running your money. |
| The media buyer juggles a lot of accounts at once. | A small, curated client roster. |
| Reports on likes, clicks and reach. | Business metrics: ROAS, CPA, revenue, LTV. |
| Template copy. | Copy written for your customer and their awareness level. |
| A PDF at the end of the month. | A 24/7 dashboard, plus the monthly report. |
| One platform, managed in a silo. | Meta, Google and TikTok working together. |
When is an agency the better pick?
There are cases where I’d point you to an agency myself:
- You need a lot of services in one place. If on top of ads you want video shoots, brand design, SEO, social media and a website, all from one vendor on one invoice, a full-service agency saves you from coordinating five people.
- You spend a lot, spread across many countries or languages. That takes a team with several people watching accounts at the same time.
- You don’t want to depend on one person. An independent can get sick or go on vacation. An agency has backups. If that keeps you up at night, ask the independent what happens in those cases.
- Your company requires corporate procurement (bids, insurance, vendor audits) that’s hard for a solo operator to handle.
An independent usually fits better if you run an online store, a service business or a B2B company that needs the decision-maker to be the one doing the work, with fast answers and no game of telephone.
Who owns the accounts and the data?
This is the most important question in this whole post, and it applies to agencies and independents alike. Your ad accounts, pixel, GA4, Tag Manager and Merchant Center should be in your company’s name. Whoever manages them comes in as a guest.
In Meta, anyone with full control of a business portfolio can share its assets, like Pages or ad accounts, with a partner (an agency, for example), per Meta’s help page on partners. When an agency works on a client’s account, the account stays in the client’s portfolio and only access is shared, as Meta explains on its page about adding ad accounts.
In Google Ads, only admin access lets someone give access to others and change access levels, per Google’s table of access levels. If an agency creates your account from its manager account, it automatically becomes the owner. Even so, the client account keeps its data and can remove that ownership by unlinking, per Google’s help on ownership of client accounts. Google also suggests having more than one admin so you don’t lose access to your tags if one person becomes unavailable (managing access).
- Create the Meta business portfolio and the Google Ads account yourself, with a company email, not a personal one.
- Put your company card on file as the payment method. That way you pay for ad spend yourself, straight to each platform.
- Share access with whoever manages them, as a partner in Meta and with standard access or by linking their manager account in Google.
- Keep at least two admins on your side. If someone leaves the company, you don’t lose the account.
- Do the same with GA4, Tag Manager, Merchant Center and the pixel. That’s your data history, and it’s worth more than any single campaign.
What should you ask before you sign?
Bring this list to the first call. The answers will tell you more than any pitch deck.
- Who will run my account day to day, and how many accounts does that person handle?
- Are the accounts in my name? What happens to them if we stop working together?
- What’s the main metric we’ll track, and what’s the target? (Not sure which one? This guide to ROAS, CPA and CPL breaks it down.)
- How is the management fee charged and what does it include? Is it separate from ad spend?
- What gets tested in month one, and when should I expect results?
- How is each conversion tracked? Who checks that the pixel and events are working?
Red flags: no admin access to your own accounts; reports packed with reach, impressions and “engagement” but not a word about sales or leads; promises of an exact ROAS before anyone has looked at your account; and an invoice where you can’t tell how much went to ads and how much to management.
About percentage fees. A lot of people charge a percentage of ad spend. It’s not a scam, but understand the incentive: the fee goes up when you spend more, not when you earn more. I charge a flat fee based on your monthly spend tier, published on my pricing page. For example, 400 a month in management for up to 2,000 in ad spend. The only exception is the top tier, where 10 percent of anything above 10,000 gets added on. I’m telling you so you can compare with everything on the table.
What should a good monthly report include?
A report is only useful if it helps you decide. If you finish reading it and still don’t know what worked or what’s next, it failed, no matter how many charts it has.
- 1What was spent
- 2What was sold
- 3Versus the target
- 4What was tested
- 5What's next
- Ad spend by platform, separate from the management fee.
- Business results: sales and revenue, or qualified leads and closed customers if you match it against your CRM.
- The main metric against the target (ROAS, CPA or CPL) and against last month.
- A comparison with your real sales, because what each platform reports doesn’t always match your bank account.
- What was tested, what won and what got turned off, and why.
- Next month’s plan, as two or three concrete decisions.
On top of the report, ask for access to live data. I give clients a 24/7 dashboard with every platform in one place, plus the monthly report, and you can see how it works in my method.
Jean's tip
If you already work with someone and want a second opinion on your account, you can ask me for a free audit. I’ll tell you what I see, even if the answer is to stay where you are.
FAQ
Is an agency or a freelancer better for running my ads?
It depends on what you need. If you want lots of services together (video production, design, SEO, social) or you spend heavily across several markets, an agency usually fits better. If you need the person making decisions to be the one running the account, with a direct line, an independent media buyer fits better.
Can an agency keep my ad account?
It can happen if the account was created inside their business portfolio or their manager account and nobody at your company has admin access. To avoid it, create the accounts yourself and give the agency partner access. In Google Ads, the client account still owns its data and can unlink the manager.
What access should I give whoever runs my campaigns?
Only what they need to do the work: in Meta, share the ad account with their portfolio as a partner; in Google Ads, give standard access or link their manager account. Full control and admin access always stay with someone at your company.
Is charging a percentage of ad spend bad?
Not necessarily, but understand the incentive: the fee goes up when your spend goes up, not when your profit does. A flat fee by spend tier keeps those two things apart. Whatever the model, ask for ad spend and management to show up as separate lines on the invoice.
Sources
- Give a partner access to business assets in your business portfolio, Meta Business Help Center
- Add an ad account to your business portfolio in Meta Business Suite, Meta Business Help Center
- About access levels in your Google Ads account, Google Ads Help
- Manager Accounts (MCC): About ownership of client accounts, Google Ads Help
- Manage access to your Google Ads account, Google Ads Help
Want this working in your account?
I start with a free audit: I review your account and your tracking, and tell you what I'd change first.